What is the Unit of Information?

October 8, 2011 5:22 am 30 comments

I was just reading a blog post by my connection John Battelle and I felt that his desire for Tapestry needs to be quenched and it gave me good reason to finally pose a question to everyone. If you just want to read the question skip to the end of this post.

Unfortunately iWish is a product Steve Jobs did not build. Else, with a magic wand you could have had Tapestry. I mean this in a respectful way. You can read my tribute to Steve(on facebook).

The question you raise is interesting yet challenging in many ways.

Let us look at what you(John) have to say:

Single Service: Surely 1 single service that brings it all togther is a dream come true. It can truly happen only if there is a way to bring all the feeds(social: so RSS won’t cut it..sad..and its an expanding set..no standards) together and somehow make semantic sense for you(the user) despite all the standard challenges(spellings/contexts) with Folksonomy.

The one way I see it happening is if 1 organization becomes that central messaging standard which can only happen if they are the big daddy of social media (Facebook). There were a zillion firms and VCs that bet their careers on Single Idendity firms(don’t need to name) but finally FConnect has been able to make it happen! Somehow, Magically every website has FConnect, that is how even your blog accepts comments. Lets bear in mind WordPress did allow single sign on across all WordPress so it worked for the Blogging Community but it did not work for everyone. Community inclusion is key. A myopic definition of community is what brings any organization to its limited success or failure. If you wish, you can read more about my ideas on Community First – 9 Elements of Corporate Strategy.

Solution: Inclusivitity.

Hence, the only way anything becomes a 100% or a near Tapestry solution is through inclusivity.

Now if I read your thought process clearly. You say that you do not want to put all your information in 1 system as it is a trust issue clearly how can we give so much power to 1 organization and let it have all my information. Assuming you mean 1 person or corporation would have God like powers and power corrupts.

However, Geogre Orwell said in 1984 ‘Freedom is Slavery’. Yes, we do not wish to hear that term in any country. So, let us understand what Mr. Orwell might have meant if he was talking about information.

Clearly, the only way you will ever get complete freedom to move information around from 1 system to another seamlessly, or aggregate information into a Tapestry or the only way knowledge(Note: not information because I think you want knowledge through tapestry – distilled information) will be truly free(Tagore) if there is a seamless way for information to move around without boundaries.

An excerpt from Tagore’s Gitanjali
Where knowledge is free (read free to move about and free from monopoly)
Where the world has not been broken up into fragments (read tweets, streams)
By narrow domestic walls (Read different social networks)
Where words come out from the depth of truth (Read Tapestry)

One could argue that something has made us all slaves of MS-Office and Windows but in the end we all win. Some people get to be on the Forbes list (its is interesting how Dead and Rich does not get anyone on the Forbes List, refer Seventh Element of Corporate strategy and its stress on a Living Mascot) and you get the freedom to move information around from 1 computer to another in a few minutes when your computer crashes(I am sorry if you are lazy on your back-ups or are not Cloud backed). Why it crashes in the first place is a discussion for another day or post.

I dread to think of a world where we use 10 different word processors.

If that were ever the case, the only gainer will be India whose BPO market will skyrocket like Medical Transcriptions and people will spend Billions of Dollars in outsoucring Document Conversions from 1 format to another.

Sir Tim Berners-Lee has been talking about the Semantic Web for a while(No, i don’t buy his implementation model) but the concept and desires are the same as Tapestry. We all want a simple and easy way to get all information so it requires lesser effort to chew.

I wonder what would happen to mankind if they eat as much as they read. Would we all be really really fat or really really dead. Do we chew enough while we read? Read less, Chew more.

Can I humbly request us all to close our eyes and ask ourselves a few simple questions:

a) What is the unit of information? (pray, please do not waste your time thinking it is
bits and bytes). E.g. Unit of Distance is Meter, Unit of Time is Seconds, Minutes, Hours. What is the Unit of Information? Is it 1 Web page? Is it a Tweet? Is it a Video in Youtube? 1 PDF from Adobe? 1 Word Document? 1 Excel Spreadsheet or 1 Cell in it? (pray, Don’t try to answer just let the thought sink in first, it takes a while)

b) Now if you have chewed enough on (a) above. Why is it that after 60 years of Technology and at least 25 years of Internet mankind has simply failed to define the ‘Unit of Information’

c) Yet, how is it in a world where juniors don’t agree with bosses, wives not with husbands, brothers not with sisters, fathers not with sons. All mankind magically agreed to the concept of a URL as a simple way to address all information on the web. (Pray, do not quote other examples like Windows as they were commercially driven monopolies. Unless you have an enlightening thought on what commercial monopolist gained or is gaining by the URL).

Today I will not make any attempt to answer the above questions. Truth be told, I have been mulling on a theory for a while. Guess its best it waits for a later post, something called BRAHMA, intentional or serendipitous i don’t know, but it surely is eponymous with the God of Creation in Hindu Mythology.

(Anyone who worked with me in the past 12 months might have already heard some of my initial thoughts so please do not comment on it just yet. Let others Chew! Yet, would love to hear comments from John or others.)


Leave a Reply

Other News

  • Big Data Cloud Computing Innovation Cloud Standards

    Cloud Standards

    The Cutter IT Journal August Issue carries an paper written on CARMA. The paper is a sneak preview of the content you can expect in the Cloud Standards book when it is out this winter. You can download a Free Copy of the Issue. If you missed our earlier conversations on Cloud and CARMA. I am in the process of writing my second book Cloud Standards, which is due later this year as part of the Cloud series, The Paradigm […]

    Read more →
  • Uncategorized Clearing the Cloud by Air India

    Clearing the Cloud by Air India

    This is to interested CEOs and CIOs in India who visit this Blog, you can now read about the Cloud when flying at 36,000 feet in Air India. In the past few months I have been talking to various CIOs and CEOs about the current state of the Cloud. What is most interesting to note is that despite so much buzz around the Cloud there is still very little clarity as to what the Cloud is all about and what […]

    Read more →
  • Big Data Cloud Computing Big Data Simplified – Part 3

    Big Data Simplified – Part 3

    In the 1st Part of this 3 Part Post we tried to understand the question : What is Big Data? Then in part 2 of this post we tried to understand the Issues with Data and the Evolution of Technology around Data. Now in this 3rd and final part of the Post we try to understand the Importance of Big Data and why Businesses should care about Big Data. Impact and Importance of Big Data on Business There are many […]

    Read more →
  • Big Data Cloud Computing Big Data Simplified – Part 2

    Big Data Simplified – Part 2

    In Part 1 of this 3 part post we tried to understand if not answer the question: What is Big Data? In Part 2 of this post we shall try understand the Issues around Big Data or Data more broadly. We shall also try and understand how technology has evolved around Data, Databases and what this means in the Big Data context. Issues with Data? Need for faster access to information, storage for larger and larger volumes of information and […]

    Read more →
  • Big Data Cloud Computing Big Data Simplified – Part 1

    Big Data Simplified – Part 1

    So, if you read the book (Cloud Basics – The Paradigm Shift) I had said it was really mean’t to be a Blog Post or a Series of Posts that ended up becoming a book. As, I write my first post on Big Data I can clearly see the need for a Book or maybe even a series of Books here that can help clear up the mist on Big Data. More over there is a need to clarify what […]

    Read more →
  • Cloud Computing Types of Private Clouds

    Types of Private Clouds

    Private Clouds are in the News. AT&T announced yesterday(Monday, 13th Feb 2012) its Virtual Private Cloud offering. It is interesting to see terminology evolve in the Cloud world. Am sure we have heard the terms Public Cloud, Private Cloud, Hybrid Cloud but maybe not Virtual Private Cloud. Telcos are big proponents of the Cloud. It is often argued that the Telcos stand to be the biggest gainers from the increased Internet Traffic and hence their desire to create new terms. […]

    Read more →
  • Business Finance Management How to get valued like Facebook, $100 Bn?

    How to get valued like Facebook, $100 Bn?

    Is Facebook worth $100 Billion? was a post made by the Wall Street Journal a few months ago which carried an interesting perspective from Geoff Yang, Founding Partner with Redpoint Ventures, Menlo Park. Geoff gave an interesting perspective on how Facebook could be valued based on its potential market share of the Ad market and the projected growth of the market by 2015. You can read the full post here. (If you know how to get past the Pay Wall […]

    Read more →
  • Health & Wellness Life Uncategorized Wisdom Do Blackholes exist on Earth?

    Do Blackholes exist on Earth?

    Blackholes exist right here on earth. What is a Blackhole?: Light goes in and is never reflected back to the source or sender. It is believed that this happens because Blackholes have a high amount of gravity and hence pull in anything that is thrown towards them. At least, so says the Theory of General Relativity. Then there is another theory called Quantum Mechanics that says Black holes are black bodies(no kidding) hence they must emit heat radiation like any […]

    Read more →

Please log in to vote

You need to log in to vote. If you already had an account, you may log in here

Alternatively, if you do not have an account yet you can create one here.